*This page contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. (info)
Filson is a premium gear brand that bridges the gap between adventurous outdoor gear and durable workwear (think loggers, ranchers, fisherman). Carhartt, in contrast, is more solely focused on creating durable workwear for tradesman (not so much adventure gear), although in recent years much of Carhartt’s gear has also been adopted as popular streetwear.
This is the most popular Filson and Carhartt gear:
- Filson Mackinaw Cruiser Jacket (click here to view)
- Carhartt Flannel-Lined Active Jacket (click here to view)
- Filson Short Lined Tin Cloth Cruiser (click here to view)
- Carhartt Rugged Flex Canvas Work Pants (click here to view)
- Filson Tin Cloth Work Duffle Bags (click here to view)
- Carhartt Rain Defender Work Hoodie (click here to view)
- Filson Mackinaw Wool Jac Shirt (click here to view)
- Carhartt Moc Toe Wedge Sole Boot (click here to view)
- Filson Oil Finish Tin Cloth Work Pants (click here to view)
- Carhartt Rugged Flex Canvas Work Shorts (click here to view)
Filson and Carhartt are two iconic brands known for their durable gear, but they serve different audiences and priorities. Filson focuses on premium materials like Tin Cloth and Mackinaw wool, offering rugged outdoor gear that blends functionality with craftsmanship.
Carhartt emphasizes affordability and practicality, using durable fabrics like canvas duck and ripstop to create reliable workwear for everyday tradesmen. This article compares their materials, construction, and overall value to help you decide which brand fits your needs.
History of Carhartt and Filson
Filson
Filson is a brand that has long been associated with durability, craftsmanship, and the outdoors. Founded in 1897 by C.C. Filson in Seattle, Washington, the company originally catered to prospectors heading to the Klondike Gold Rush.
Filson’s early focus was on creating gear that could withstand harsh climates and demanding conditions. This commitment to quality helped the brand gain a loyal following among hunters, anglers, and outdoor enthusiasts.
The company specializes in high-quality materials like waxed cotton, tin cloth, Mackinaw wool and Seattle wool. These materials are chosen for their ability to endure rough conditions while offering protection from the elements.
See my video here testing the water-resistance of Filson Mackinaw wool:
Over the years, Filson has expanded its product line to include jackets, shirts, bags, and accessories, but it has never strayed far from its outdoor roots. Each product is designed with functionality and timeless style in mind, appealing to those who value quality over trends.
Filson’s pricing reflects its premium status. The brand positions itself as an investment, emphasizing longevity and craftsmanship. This has made Filson a favorite among professionals in demanding industries and outdoor aficionados who see their gear as a lifetime companion.
Carhartt
Carhartt, on the other hand, is a brand synonymous with workwear. Founded in 1889 by Hamilton Carhartt in Detroit, Michigan, the company initially focused on creating overalls for railroad workers.
From the beginning, Carhartt aimed to serve the needs of laborers by producing durable, practical clothing that could withstand the rigors of physical labor.
Carhartt’s products are crafted from tough materials like heavyweight duck cotton and ripstop fabric. The brand is particularly known for its double-stitched seams and reinforced designs, which offer exceptional durability.
While its primary audience has historically been blue-collar workers, Carhartt has gained popularity among a broader audience, including outdoor enthusiasts, students, and urban fashion consumers.
Unlike Filson, Carhartt has a more accessible price point. The brand strikes a balance between affordability and durability, making it a go-to choice for individuals who need reliable workwear on a budget. Its product lineup includes jackets, overalls, pants, shirts, and accessories, all designed with utility in mind.
Carhartt also has a reputation for evolving with its customers. The company has embraced modern trends by introducing lines like Carhartt WIP (Work In Progress), which blends traditional workwear styles with a more fashion-forward approach. This adaptability has helped Carhartt remain relevant to a diverse customer base.
Comparing Materials
Filson and Carhartt both prioritize quality and durability, but they approach these goals in distinct ways, reflecting their core audiences and brand philosophies. Filson focuses on premium materials like Mackinaw wool and cotton Tin Cloth, which are designed to endure the harshest outdoor conditions.
Carhartt, on the other hand, emphasizes functional durability through the widespread use of canvas duck, ripstop fabrics, and affordability, catering to tradesmen and workers seeking reliable gear.
Filson’s Materials
Filson’s reputation for rugged yet refined gear rests on its use of premium materials. Mackinaw wool, one of the brand’s hallmark fabrics, is a densely woven material made from sheep’s wool.
Known for its exceptional warmth and natural water resistance, Mackinaw wool retains heat even when wet, making it ideal for cold, damp environments. This wool is sourced for durability and comfort, often featured in coats and jackets designed for outdoor professionals and adventurers.
Tin Cloth is another standout material from Filson. This durable, tightly woven cotton canvas is treated with oil or wax, making it highly resistant to water, wind, and wear. Originally created for loggers in the Pacific Northwest, Tin Cloth excels in protecting against abrasive outdoor environments (think forestry).
In the video below, I show how Filson Tin Cloth repels water:
Filson also offers Cover Cloth and Shelter Cloth, which are lighter-weight versions of Tin Cloth. Cover Cloth is ideal for moderate weather, while Shelter Cloth strikes a balance between flexibility and durability, making it suitable for layering or lighter tasks.
The waxed or oiled finish of Tin Cloth not only provides superior weather resistance but also develops a unique patina over time, reflecting years of use. This feature gives Filson gear a timeless appeal, but it also requires periodic re-waxing to maintain its protective qualities.
Carhartt’s Materials
Carhartt’s approach to durability lies in its extensive use of canvas duck, a tightly woven cotton fabric renowned for its strength and resistance to tearing. Unlike Filson Tin Cloth, Carhartt’s canvas duck is typically untreated, resulting in a dry finish.
While this makes it less water-resistant than waxed fabrics, many Carhartt pieces are treated with durable water repellent (DWR) coatings to provide weather protection without the maintenance required by oiled fabrics.
I personally love to wear the Carhartt J140 Flannel-Lined Jacket:
Carhartt has also embraced innovations like stretch canvas, which blends traditional durability with increased flexibility, making it ideal for active workers who need both strength and mobility in their clothing. Types of Carhartt Jackets
For warm-weather gear, Carhartt frequently uses ripstop fabric, a lightweight material designed to resist tearing while offering breathability – perfect for summer conditions or physically demanding jobs in hot climates.
Cost Considerations
Filson’s emphasis on premium materials and its commitment to craftsmanship often result in higher prices. Many of Filson’s products are sewn in the USA, adding to their appeal as premium gear designed to last for decades. This focus on quality and heritage positions Filson as a brand for those who see their gear as an investment.
Carhartt, while also highly respected, targets a broader audience. Its affordability and dependability make it a go-to choice for everyday workers who need rugged clothing they can trust. Although Carhartt’s gear is less expensive than Filson’s, it delivers exceptional value, making it a practical option for those who prioritize function over premium materials.